Two are tenors; the other a bass. The deep singe is the comedian, but he is ever so much better as a bass. In fact, his vocal efforts are so far superior to the “cissyfied” comedy that he should forget his humorous inclinations.
The singing is not up to par, but the taller tenor has a fair solo voice. It would be much better to make a straight act of it. In the present form “The Gotham Trio” will not pass through.
Variety 2:3 (02/16/1907)