A first-rate tenor gives the quartet strength. This voice is pleasingly noticeable in the harmony. The bass did not carry very well in the ensemble numbers.
The Avon Comedy Four seem to be a bit uncertain whether they are a singing quartet or a company of knockabout comedians. They push their talk much too far, and the really agreeable singing is used scarcely at all until near the finish.
Variety 6:5 (06/29/1907)