Phil Sheridan

Type:
"Marathon Girls", including the acts "The March of the U. S. A." and "Hats Off to the Navy,". The "Aeroplane" song is there without the aeroplane, and the last scene of the second act is the "Polo Grounds, New York." Mr. Evans is the main comedian, working in a sort of tramp make-up, but without further character. Between himself, Billy Welp, funny through a make-up and Johnstone Flynn, a cissified dude who isn't cissified or dude enough, but sings perfectly so no one understands the words, there are many laughs in the show. Two of the best songs of the evening were sung by Hugo Angelo. "The Six Irish Colleens." sing and try to dance. Clare Evans and Babette present a sketch in the olio called "The Wrong Mr. Souse."
Source:
Variety 16:4 (10/02/1909)